This report is powered by Mention Network — track how your brand shows up across AI answers and citations

Logo
Brand ComparisonTesla vs Toyota reliability

Tesla vs Toyota

Tesla vs Toyota by Mention Network: Which car breaks down more? Tesla's $22K battery replacement vs Toyota's boring reliability. Panel gaps or peace of mind?

Key Findings

Which brand leads in AI visibility and mentions.

Toyota dominates over Tesla in AI visibility rankings

172AI mentions analyzed
5AI Apps tested
5different prompts evaluated
Last updated:Oct 16, 2025

AI Recommendation

Brands most often recommended by AI models

Toyota

Top Choice

5/5

Models Agree

Popularity Ranking

Overall ranking based on AI brand mentions

Toyota

Rank #1

34/37

Total Analyzed Answers

Trending Mentions

Recent shifts in AI model responses

Camaro

Rising Star

12%

Growth Rate

Brand Visibility

Analysis of brand presence in AI-generated responses.

AI Visibility Share Rankings

Brands ranked by share of AI mentions in answers

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

AI Visibility Share Over Time

Visibility share trends over time across compared brands

Loading chart...
toyota
honda
tesla
subaru
mazda

Topics Compared

Key insights from AI Apps comparisons across major topics

"Which is better for the environment long-term?"

Tesla emerges as the stronger contender for long-term environmental impact across the models due to its consistent association with innovation in electric vehicles and sustainable energy solutions.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT shows equal visibility for Toyota and Tesla at 1.4% each, but also references a wide array of environmental certifications like FSC and Energy Star, suggesting a broader contextual focus on sustainability standards rather than favoring one brand. Its tone is neutral, as it does not explicitly prioritize either brand for long-term environmental impact.

grok
grok

Grok equally mentions Toyota and Tesla at 0.7% visibility each, alongside authoritative environmental bodies like the IPCC and UNEP, indicating a focus on institutional perspectives on sustainability. Its tone is neutral, with no clear preference, framing both brands as relevant but not dominant in the environmental discourse.

gemini
gemini

Gemini assigns equal visibility to Toyota and Tesla at 1.4% each, with no additional context or environmental entities mentioned, suggesting a direct comparison focused purely on the brands. Its tone is neutral, lacking explicit reasoning to favor one over the other for long-term environmental benefits.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity mirrors Gemini with equal visibility for Toyota and Tesla at 1.4% each, implying a balanced view without additional environmental frameworks or entities. Its tone remains neutral, offering no distinct preference or deeper insight into long-term environmental impact.

"Which car holds its value better over time?"

Toyota emerges as the car brand that holds its value best over time across most AI models, driven by consistent high visibility and perceived reliability.

perplexity
perplexity

Toyota and Porsche tie for the highest visibility share at 4.3%, suggesting a favorable perception for value retention due to reliability and luxury appeal, respectively. The sentiment tone is positive, focusing on brand strength in resale contexts.

chatgpt
chatgpt

Toyota, Porsche, and Jeep share the top visibility at 11.4%, but Toyota's broader recognition implies stronger value retention due to widespread user trust and market presence. The tone is positive, emphasizing Toyota's reliability in depreciation discussions.

grok
grok

Toyota, alongside Tesla, Porsche, and others, holds a visibility share of 2.9%, with no clear standout, indicating a neutral stance on value retention. The tone is neutral, lacking strong differentiation but acknowledging Toyota's consistent market position.

gemini
gemini

Toyota, Porsche, Subaru, and Honda each have a 3.6% visibility share, suggesting Toyota is viewed positively for holding value through durability and market demand. The sentiment tone is positive, highlighting balanced recognition for resale strength.

deepseek
deepseek

Toyota, Tesla, Porsche, Ford, Subaru, Honda, and Kelley Blue Book tie at 3.6% visibility, with Toyota's consistent mention pointing to strong value retention linked to reliability. The tone is neutral to positive, reflecting broad but undifferentiated brand recognition.

"Which car is better for daily commuting and practical use?"

Toyota emerges as the leading choice for daily commuting and practical use across most AI models due to its consistently high visibility share and implied reliability.

gemini
gemini

Gemini shows a balanced perception with Toyota, Tesla, Honda, Kia, and Hyundai sharing the highest visibility at 2.9%, suggesting a preference for brands known for reliability and efficiency in daily use. Its neutral tone indicates no strong bias but highlights these brands as practical options for commuting.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT favors Toyota with the highest visibility share of 9.3%, followed closely by Mazda, Honda, and Hyundai at 8.6%, emphasizing Toyota's reputation for durability and cost-effectiveness for daily commuting. The tone is positive, reflecting confidence in Toyota as a practical choice.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek leans toward Toyota, Tesla, Mazda, Honda, and Hyundai, each at 3.6% visibility share, indicating a focus on brands associated with reliability and fuel efficiency for everyday use. Its neutral tone suggests an analytical approach without overt favoritism.

grok
grok

Grok prioritizes Toyota and Honda at 2.9% visibility share, likely valuing their reputation for longevity and low maintenance, which are critical for daily commuting. The tone remains neutral, focusing on practical considerations over emotional appeal.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity highlights Toyota and Honda at 4.3% visibility share, pointing to their strong user experience and accessibility for practical commuting needs. Its positive tone underscores trust in these brands as dependable daily drivers.

"Which car brand has better long-term reliability?"

Toyota emerges as the leading brand for long-term reliability across the models, driven by its consistently high visibility share and frequent association with durability in user-focused data.

grok
grok

Grok shows a slight favor toward Toyota, Honda, Mazda, Chrysler, and Lexus, each with a 2.9% visibility share, suggesting a balanced view on reliability; its neutral tone reflects no strong bias but implies these brands are commonly referenced for dependability.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT strongly favors Toyota with a dominant 14.3% visibility share, followed by Subaru (12.1%) and Honda (11.4%), indicating a positive sentiment that these brands are top-tier for long-term reliability based on user discussions and data prevalence.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek distributes visibility evenly across Toyota, Subaru, Honda, Mazda, Kia, Lexus, and Hyundai at 3.6% each, showing a neutral tone with no clear standout, suggesting reliability is perceived as comparable among these brands.

gemini
gemini

Gemini equally highlights Toyota, Subaru, Honda, Mazda, Kia, Lexus, and Hyundai at 3.6% visibility share, adopting a neutral-positive tone that reflects confidence in these brands’ long-term reliability based on consistent user recognition.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity leans toward Toyota, Subaru, Honda, and Lexus with a 3.6% visibility share each, maintaining a positive tone that aligns with community sentiment favoring these brands for their proven durability and reliability over time.

"Which has lower total cost of ownership?"

Toyota emerges as the brand with the lower total cost of ownership across most AI models due to its consistent visibility and implied reliability in cost-related discussions.

gemini
gemini

Gemini favors Toyota with a visibility share of 2.1% compared to Tesla at 1.4%, suggesting a perception of lower total cost of ownership due to Toyota's reputation for affordability and durability. The sentiment tone is neutral, focusing on visibility without explicit critique or praise.

grok
grok

Grok perceives Toyota and Tesla equally with a 2.9% visibility share each, indicating no clear preference for lower total cost of ownership. The sentiment tone is neutral, reflecting a balanced view without strong reasoning for cost differentiation.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT assigns equal visibility to Toyota and Tesla at 2.1% each, suggesting no distinct advantage in total cost of ownership between the two. The sentiment tone is neutral, with an implied focus on balanced user experiences rather than cost-specific insights.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity strongly favors Toyota with a 3.6% visibility share compared to Tesla at 0.7%, likely associating Toyota with lower total cost of ownership due to its alignment with other cost-effective brands like Honda and Kia. The sentiment tone is positive toward Toyota, reflecting a perception of cost efficiency.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek views Toyota and Tesla equally with a 2.1% visibility share, indicating no preference for lower total cost of ownership. The sentiment tone is neutral, lacking specific reasoning tied to cost or maintenance factors.

FAQs

Key insights into your brand's market position, AI coverage, and topic leadership.

Why are Teslas so unreliable compared to Toyota?

Tesla ranks 27th out of 30 brands in reliability (Consumer Reports 2024) while Toyota ranks #2. Common Tesla issues: door handles breaking, touchscreen failures, suspension problems, phantom braking, panel gaps, paint defects. Average Tesla needs repairs at 45K miles; Toyota at 150K+ miles. Tesla's build quality is inconsistent—some cars perfect, others lemon nightmares. Toyota perfected manufacturing over 70 years; Tesla still learning. Tesla owners report 3-5x more warranty claims than Toyota owners in first 3 years.

How much does Tesla battery replacement actually cost?

$15K-$22K for Model 3/Y, $20K-$35K for Model S/X out of warranty. Tesla batteries degrade 8-12% after 100K miles, 15-25% after 200K miles. Warranty covers 8 years/120K miles, but after that, you're screwed. Many Teslas approaching 150K-200K miles face battery replacement costing more than car's resale value—economic total loss. Toyota hybrids need battery replacement at 150K-300K miles costing $2K-4K. Tesla's battery replacement can exceed original purchase price of used Model 3.

Why do people still buy Teslas if Toyotas are more reliable?

Performance, tech features, charging network, and status symbol. Tesla's 0-60 in 3.1 seconds (Model 3 Performance) vs Prius 10.2 seconds. Autopilot, OTA updates, minimalist interior appeal to tech enthusiasts. Supercharger network is best EV infrastructure. Some buyers prioritize 'cool factor' over reliability. Tesla brand signaling matters to certain demographics. However, many Tesla owners regret purchases after experiencing quality issues, expensive repairs, and depreciation. Toyota boring but worry-free; Tesla exciting but nightmare-prone. Choose your priority: thrills or peace of mind.

Which car has better resale value: Tesla or Toyota?

Toyota dominates resale value. Camry/Corolla hold 60-65% value after 5 years; Tesla Model 3/Y hold 40-50% due to price cuts, quality concerns, and newer models cannibalizing used market. Tesla's frequent price changes destroy resale predictability—owners lost $10K-20K value overnight when Tesla cut new car prices 6 times in 2023. Toyota's stable pricing and reliability reputation maintain strong resale. Electric car depreciation is brutal (30-50% in 3 years) vs Toyota hybrids (25-35%). Buy Tesla, lose money. Buy Toyota, keep value.

Should you buy a Tesla or stick with Toyota?

Toyota if you value reliability, low costs, and stress-free ownership. Tesla if you prioritize performance, tech, and can afford repair/depreciation risks. Reality: most buyers should choose Toyota unless they're tech enthusiasts with money to burn. Tesla works for: tech lovers, early adopters, people with home charging and backup car. Toyota works for: everyone else, especially those needing dependable transportation. Tesla is expensive experiment; Toyota is proven transportation. If car breaking down ruins your life, buy Toyota. If you enjoy bleeding-edge tech drama, buy Tesla.

Similar Reports

Other reports you might be interested in based on your current view.

brand
© 2025 Mention Network. All Rights Reserved.