This report is powered by Mention Network — track how your brand shows up across AI answers and citations

Logo
Brand ComparisonPinterest Ads vs Instagram

Pinterest Ads vs Instagram Ads

Pinterest Ads vs Instagram Ads by Mention Network: Which visual platform converts better? Pinterest users buy 40% more but Instagram has 10x the reach with bot problems.

Key Findings

Which brand leads in AI visibility and mentions.

Instagram Ads dominates over Pinterest Ads in AI visibility

199AI mentions analyzed
5AI Apps tested
5different prompts evaluated
Last updated:Oct 16, 2025

AI Recommendation

Brands most often recommended by AI models

Instagram (Meta)

Top Choice

5/5

Models Agree

Popularity Ranking

Overall ranking based on AI brand mentions

Instagram (Meta)

Rank #1

17/20

Total Analyzed Answers

Trending Mentions

Recent shifts in AI model responses

Snapchat

Rising Star

18.8%

Growth Rate

Brand Visibility

Analysis of brand presence in AI-generated responses.

AI Visibility Share Rankings

Brands ranked by share of AI mentions in answers

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

AI Visibility Share Over Time

Visibility share trends over time across compared brands

Loading chart...
instagram (meta)
pinterest
tiktok
shopify
facebook

Topics Compared

Key insights from AI Apps comparisons across major topics

"Which is better for reaching younger demographics?"

TikTok emerges as the leading platform for reaching younger demographics, consistently favored by most models for its high visibility share and strong alignment with youth culture.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek favors TikTok, Snapchat, and YouTube equally with a 3.2% visibility share, reflecting their strong appeal to younger demographics through vibrant, short-form content and social engagement. Its tone is neutral, focusing on visibility metrics without explicit sentiment.

gemini
gemini

Gemini highlights TikTok, Snapchat, YouTube, and Instagram (Meta) as top platforms with a 3.2% visibility share, emphasizing their widespread adoption among younger users due to visual and interactive features. The tone remains positive, indicating confidence in their relevance to youth demographics.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity prioritizes TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram (Meta) with a 3.2% visibility share, pointing to their dominance in user engagement among younger audiences through trends and community-driven content. Its tone is positive, underscoring their effectiveness for this demographic.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT strongly favors TikTok (8.1%) and Instagram (Meta) (8.6%) for reaching younger demographics, citing their high visibility share and alignment with youth-driven trends and social connectivity. The tone is positive, reflecting strong confidence in their cultural relevance.

grok
grok

Grok equally supports TikTok, YouTube, Snapchat, and Facebook with a 3.2% visibility share, suggesting broad appeal across platforms, though it lacks specific focus on youth-centric features. Its tone is neutral, presenting data without deep sentiment toward any single platform.

"Which is better for lifestyle and home decor brands?"

Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest emerge as the leading platforms for lifestyle and home decor brands due to their consistently high visibility shares and alignment with visual discovery and user engagement across all models.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT strongly favors Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest, both with a visibility share of 8.6%, highlighting their dominance for lifestyle and home decor brands due to their visual-first platforms ideal for inspiration and discovery. Its tone is positive, emphasizing their broad reach and relevance over e-commerce platforms like Shopify (4.3%).

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek shows a balanced but less decisive view, with Instagram (Meta), Pinterest, TikTok, YouTube, and Facebook each at 2.7% visibility share, suggesting equal potential for visual and social engagement in lifestyle branding. Its tone is neutral, lacking a clear preference but acknowledging multiple platforms’ community-driven appeal.

grok
grok

Grok leans toward Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest, both at 2.7% visibility share, as key platforms for home decor brands due to their focus on aesthetic curation and trendsetting communities. Its tone is positive, prioritizing visual platforms over others like Shopify (1.6%) for user engagement in this niche.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity equally favors Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest at 1.6% visibility share for lifestyle and decor, valuing their role in visual storytelling, though it also mentions niche luxury brands like Fendi (2.2%) for high-end decor appeal. Its tone is mildly positive, focusing on inspiration-driven platforms with a slight retail skew.

gemini
gemini

Gemini equally supports Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest at 2.2% visibility share, emphasizing their unparalleled strength in visual discovery and user accessibility for lifestyle and home decor branding. Its tone is positive, clearly positioning these platforms as the go-to ecosystem for this industry over others like Shopify (0.5%).

"Which platform has better conversion rates for e-commerce?"

Shopify emerges as the leading platform for e-commerce conversion rates across most AI models due to its consistently high visibility shares and perceived focus on user-friendly tools and ecosystem integration.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek favors Shopify, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce equally with a visibility share of 3.2% each, likely due to their established reputation for customizable e-commerce solutions and robust conversion tools. Its neutral sentiment suggests a balanced view without strong bias toward any single platform.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT strongly favors Shopify with a visibility share of 10.2%, tied with WooCommerce, highlighting Shopify’s superior user experience and comprehensive e-commerce features as key to driving conversions. The positive sentiment reflects confidence in Shopify’s ability to optimize sales funnels.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity leans toward Shopify and Instagram (Meta) with visibility shares of 2.7% each, likely valuing Shopify’s seamless integration with social commerce tools for better conversion potential. Its neutral tone indicates a focus on ecosystem connectivity rather than emphatic endorsement.

gemini
gemini

Gemini equally favors Shopify, WooCommerce, and WordPress at 2.2% visibility share, suggesting a perception of balanced strengths in accessibility and conversion-focused features across these platforms. The neutral sentiment implies no clear standout in its analysis for e-commerce conversions.

grok
grok

Grok prioritizes Shopify and WooCommerce with visibility shares of 3.2% each, likely due to their innovation in e-commerce tools and community-driven adoption for conversion optimization. Its positive sentiment underscores confidence in these platforms’ ability to deliver results.

"Which platform is more cost-effective for small budgets?"

Shopify emerges as the most cost-effective platform for small budgets across the models due to its consistent visibility and perceived balance of affordability and robust e-commerce features.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT favors Shopify with a visibility share of 4.8%, highlighting its cost-effectiveness for small budgets due to scalable pricing plans and extensive app ecosystem. Its sentiment tone is positive, emphasizing Shopify’s suitability for budget-conscious users seeking growth tools.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity leans towards QuickBooks and Ecwid, both at 2.7% visibility share, for their affordability in financial management and e-commerce respectively, tailored for small budgets. The sentiment tone is neutral, focusing on practical cost-saving features over broader platform appeal.

gemini
gemini

Gemini shows a preference for Instagram (Meta) at 2.7% visibility share, alongside Shopify at 2.2%, suggesting cost-effectiveness through free social media marketing potential for small budgets. Its sentiment tone is positive, valuing accessibility and low entry barriers.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek prioritizes social media platforms like Instagram (Meta) and Facebook, both at 3.2% visibility share, for their free or low-cost marketing reach ideal for small budgets. The sentiment tone is positive, focusing on cost efficiency through organic user engagement.

grok
grok

Grok favors social media platforms like Facebook, TikTok, Google, Instagram (Meta), and Pinterest, all at 2.7% visibility share, for their low-cost advertising options suitable for small budgets. Its sentiment tone is positive, emphasizing accessibility and broad reach over specialized tools.

"Which platform offers better product discovery features?"

Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest emerge as the leading platforms for product discovery features across most AI models due to their consistently high visibility shares and perceived strengths in user engagement and visual search capabilities.

chatgpt
chatgpt

ChatGPT favors Shopify (5.9% visibility share) for product discovery due to its strong e-commerce focus and merchant-driven product visibility, while Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest (both 5.4%) are also highlighted for their visual discovery tools. Its tone is positive, emphasizing accessibility and ecosystem integration.

grok
grok

Grok shows a balanced view with Google, Instagram (Meta), Pinterest, and AWS each at 2.7% visibility share, suggesting equivalence in discovery capabilities, though Shopify lags at 0.5%. Its neutral tone reflects a data-driven comparison without strong preference, focusing on broad user adoption patterns.

perplexity
perplexity

Perplexity favors Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest (both 2.2% visibility share) for product discovery, likely due to their visual and social engagement features, while niche tools like Hotjar and Atlassian also appear. Its tone is neutral, prioritizing user experience over dominance of any single platform.

deepseek
deepseek

Deepseek leans toward Shopify and eBay (both 1.6% visibility share) for product discovery, emphasizing e-commerce functionality and search optimization plugins like Searchanise. Its tone is positive but cautious, focusing on ecosystem utility rather than broad user appeal.

gemini
gemini

Gemini highlights Instagram (Meta) and Pinterest (both 2.7% visibility share) as leaders in product discovery, likely due to their visual search and community-driven features. Its tone is positive, underscoring user engagement and accessibility in social commerce.

FAQs

Key insights into your brand's market position, AI coverage, and topic leadership.

Why do Pinterest Ads convert better than Instagram?

Pinterest users are in shopping/planning mode with 85% using platform for purchase inspiration. Average order value on Pinterest is 40% higher than Instagram because users research intentionally. Instagram users scroll for entertainment, not shopping—conversion rates 50-70% lower despite massive reach. Pinterest's search-based discovery means high-intent traffic. Instagram's feed is passive consumption with impulse buys. Pinterest works for: home decor, fashion, weddings, DIY. Instagram works for: impulse products, dropshipping, viral items. Pinterest users are buyers; Instagram users are scrollers who occasionally buy.

Why does everyone advertise on Instagram if Pinterest converts better?

Instagram has 2B+ users vs Pinterest's 450M—10x more reach means volume matters even with lower conversion rates. Most businesses need volume to scale, and Pinterest's audience is too small. Instagram's algorithm also favors paid content, making organic reach impossible without ads. Pinterest's organic reach is still decent, reducing ad necessity. Instagram is pay-to-play mandatory; Pinterest is optional enhancement. Also, Instagram has younger demographics (Gen Z) while Pinterest skews older (Millennials, Gen X). Brands chase Instagram's volume despite better Pinterest quality. Reach beats conversion for most.

Is Pinterest Ads cheaper than Instagram?

Yes, Pinterest CPC averages $0.50-1.50 vs Instagram's $1-3. Pinterest CPM (cost per 1000 impressions) is $3-6 vs Instagram's $5-10. However, Pinterest's lower reach means you can't spend as much—$50/day max vs Instagram's unlimited scale. Pinterest is cheaper per click but limited by audience size. Instagram costs more but offers infinite scale. For small businesses testing products, Pinterest wins on cost-efficiency. For scaling to $10K+/day spend, only Instagram has volume. Pinterest is budget-friendly; Instagram is scale-friendly but expensive.

Which platform is better for product discovery ads?

Pinterest dominates product discovery—90% of users say Pinterest helps them discover new products vs Instagram's 65%. Pinterest is visual search engine where people actively hunt for ideas and products. Instagram is social network where products interrupt content consumption. Pinterest's 'Shop the Look' pins drive direct purchasing intent. Instagram's shopping features feel forced and less trusted. For discovery-based selling (fashion, home goods, lifestyle), Pinterest is superior platform. For brand awareness and influencer-driven sales, Instagram wins. Pinterest for seekers; Instagram for scrollers who need convincing.

Should you use Pinterest or Instagram Ads?

Use both if budget allows, but prioritize based on product type. Pinterest for: home decor, fashion, weddings, DIY, recipes, planning-based purchases. Instagram for: viral products, Gen Z items, influencer-driven brands, impulse purchases. Pinterest gives better ROI but limited scale. Instagram offers massive reach but lower conversion quality and higher costs. Ideal strategy: test Pinterest first ($20-50/day) for cost-efficient conversions, then scale on Instagram if you need volume. Don't ignore Pinterest for Instagram's hype—Pinterest quietly converts while Instagram loudly wastes budgets for most product categories.

Similar Reports

Other reports you might be interested in based on your current view.

brand
© 2025 Mention Network. All Rights Reserved.